REVIEW: Glen Hansard - It Was Triumph We Once Proposed

Glen Hansard
It Was Triumph We Once Proposed...The Songs Of Jason Molina




“I think covers are important; I’ve seen it in its maximum power.”  Jason Molina spoke these words in an interview in 2010, three years before his passing. 

For the uninitiated, Molina was an ultra-prolific songwriter and the driving force behind the bands Songs: Ohia and Magnolia Electric Co.  Between 1996 and 2009, Molina, with the help of a rotating cast of collaborators, issued upwards of 35 releases credited to both bands as well as his own name.  His sound ranged from the lo-fi indie rock of the former to alternative country twang of the latter, unified by the stark imagery of his lyrics and a penchant for beautiful melodies.  He died of alcohol related complications in March of 2013.

Glen Hansard knew Jason Molina well.  The Frames frontman had invited Molina to tour Ireland after falling in love with Songs: Ohia’s debut record – one which he purchased on a whim.  Molina took him up on the offer, and the two became friends, even releasing a split 7” record together in 2000.  Fifteen years later, Hansard is offering up a tribute to the songwriter he admired so much.  It Was Triumph We Once Proposed…The Songs Of Jason Molina finds Hansard taking on five Molina tunes, backed by former members of Songs: Ohia.

The EP begins with “Being In Love”, from 2000s The Lioness.  Here Hansard and company have traded the originals steady wash of organ and programmed drum beat for a more conventional wavering rock structure.  Driven by a curiously catchy guitar lead, Hansard takes on one of Molina’s greatest lines in a mellow voice.  “Being in love means you are completely broken,” he sings, “then put back together.  The one piece that was yours is beating in your lover’s breast.  She says the same thing about hers.” Jennie Benfords backing vocals add a warmness to the last line as the band begins to build itself towards its dramatic conclusion. 

If “Being In Love” is the most ambitious reinterpretation, “Hold On, Magnolia” is the most faithful of the group.  Staying true to the originals melancholy nature, the band hangs back just enough to let the piano line carry the song.   Hansard owns the vocal here more than anywhere else on the EP.  Whether he is singing it to himself or his lost friend is up to interpretation, but there is a feeling of strong emotions as he belts out the final line: “I think it’s almost time.”

Quite the opposite approach is taken to one of Molina’s most popular songs, “Farewell Transmission”.  Known as the loud, hard rocking album opener, here it has been reduced to its most basic parts.  The lap steels popular lead line is played by a guitar mixed gently underneath an ethereal arpeggiated chord.  Two thirds of the way through, things kick up, but never quite with the ferocity the song is known for before it slowly dissipates into silence.

The final two tracks are selections from the self-titled Songs: Ohia debut.  “Vanquisher” stays fairly true to the original, an upbeat rocker that trades its banjo for an electric guitar.  Benford and Hansards voice play well off each other in this more upbeat dynamic.  But it’s “White Sulfur” that showcases the true cathartic nature of this project.  It’s a track that won’t make many lists of Molina favorites, which makes it all the more endearing.  Accompanied only by his acoustic guitar, there is a clear connection between song and singer.  Hansard’s voice falters slightly as he closes the record with “I have to be going.  Okay.”

Jason Molina was right – covers are important.  Great songs carry with them the capability to be reinterpreted.  In the right hands, those songs can continue to transcend cultures and generations, meeting new audiences all the time.  We lost one of the great writers, but thanks to Glen Hansard, Molina’s songs will continue to live on. 


Listen to Glen Hansard performing "Hold On, Magnolia" live below:







Comments