REVIEW: Cave In f/ Stephen Brodsky & Adam McGrath - Live At Roadburn 2018

Cave In f/ Stephen Brodsky & Adam McGrath
Live At Roadburn 2018



At the 2018 edition of Roadburn Festival in the Netherlands, founding Cave In members Stephen Brodsky and Adam McGrath played a special set dedicated to the their longtime bandmate Caleb Scofield.  Scofield, who was also a member of Old Man Gloom and founder of the band Zozobra, had died tragically in March of that year, just under a month before the duo played their memorial show.  His passing sparked a number of events celebrating his life and music while also serving to benefit the family that he had left behind.

Scofield was an ultra-talented musician whose bass tone was as savage as his screamed vocals.  In Cave In, his creative bass lines anchored the spaciness of the bands early material, but his presence became much more prominent as the group expanded their sound.  Their later output, albums like Perfect Pitch Black and White Silence brought Scofield’s vocals front and center while his skillful playing style began to fuel the songs more than ground them.

Along with members of Isis and Converge, Scofield helped make up the sludge-metal “supergroup” Old Man Gloom.  Known for their insanely heavy and complex riffs, the bass player/vocalist helped to forge the bands eccentric sound, even contributing what drummer Santos Montano called “dusty cowboy” acoustic songs for each record.  But perhaps Scofield’s most impressive output was with his rotating membership group Zozobra.  As the songwriter as well as recording guitar, bass and vocals, Zozobra’s three records were truly a product of his talent.

Scofield was clearly a well-respected musician amongst the metal scene.  Benefit shows were played featuring bands like Converge and The Cancer Conspiracy as well as Cave In and Old Man Gloom.  Isis even played a one night only reunion set in his honor.  His friends and former bandmates played his Zozobra songs together closing out both the Boston and L.A. memorial shows while dozens of bands and music related companies donated merchandise to be raffled for his family.

On Live At Roadburn, two of Scofields closest friends pay tribute, offering a number of Cave In songs meaningful to them as well as to the fans.  Brodsky sings and plays acoustic while McGrath adds cosmic accompaniment through effect-drenched electric guitar.  The duo opens with “Youth Overrided” from their major label release Antenna.  The song is about the troubles that come with the realization of growing older, and in this circumstance so close to the loss of a friend, the emotion of the track runs high.  Brodsky’s voice slightly cracks on the high notes, noting later that this is one of the hardest things he has ever had to do.

The eclectic and superb Tides Of Tomorrow EP is visited three times in the set.  Brodsky and McGrath run through beautiful stripped down versions of “Dark Driving”, “Everest” and “The Calypso”, the latter a Scofield penned song prophesizing the bands negative major label experience.  Cave In’s landmark space-rock record Jupiter makes appearances with the acoustic first half of “New Moon” (that cleverly seques into “Dark Driving”) as well as crowd favorite “Big Riff” played in the two-piece setup for possibly the first time ever.

It is perhaps the songs off the last Cave In record that seem to have the most meaning on this album, though.  Prior to playing “Heartbreaks, Earthquakes”, White Silence’s noisy Pink Floyd meets Radiohead pop song, Brodsky mentions the significant impact that Scofield had on writing the record. His imprint is noticeable from the starting moments of White Silence, but none as clearly evident than on “Sing My Loves”, one of the bands standout tracks.  Without the driving bass and vicious vocals of Scofield, Brodsky and McGrath stick to the songs anthemic closing section.  The somber tone of the set changes to that of hopeful healing as Brodsky wails the lyrics “Sing my loves/ Sing my enemies/ Sing my sorrows/ We will all sing.”

Caleb Scofield was an incredible musician and voice in the metal and hardcore scene.  His unmistakable screams and true musicianship is one that will be missed.  This record is a must for fans of Cave In or anything Scofield related.  Anybody not familiar with his work would be wise to check it out right now.


Harmonic Tremors: Mini Documentary About Caleb Scofield Benefit Shows


Comments